Today, I’m presenting another film in the Cinema Second Look Series. To recap, this is where I revisit films that are misunderstood, miscategorized, or got something wrong.
Today we’re going to look at is Law Abiding Citizen, starring Jamie Foxx and Gerard Butler. This first caught my eye when it was featured on my local news due to production taking place in Philadelphia.

The premise of the film is Gerard Butler’s wife and daughter are killed in a home invasion as he is left for dead. The local prosecutor, played by Jamie Foxx, has a high conviction rate and wants to keep it that way. So he strikes a plea bargain with the “mastermind” of the invasion. He pleads to a lesser charge while testifying against the other man, who is sentenced to death. Gerard Butler feels betrayed by the system and takes matters into his own hands to punish the system, including perpetrating acts while still in a jail cell.
It did okay business and got mixed reviews. And to me, the reason is simple: They marketed it as a straight-up thriller, instead of a tragedy.
The first thing the movie shows is Gerard Butler’s family getting killed and after we learn about Jamie Foxx’s professional and family life (he is never home for his daughter’s events), we see how the system betrays Gerard Butler. I completely sympathize with Butler’s character and I feel for him. Maybe I am biased because I am a father myself. I relate 100% to his character. In no way, shape or form do I feel anything positive to Jamie Foxx’s character. He works all the time and is overly concerned with his conviction rate. No wonder his family life suffers! He has his priorities out of whack. And given how the system has treated millions in this country, this film does nothing to warrant me, or many others, to root for Jamie Foxx and the side of the law.
Now I don’t condone the actions Gerard Butler takes. They are heinous and one could argue are worse than what happens to him. To paraphrase Chris Rock, what he did was not right, but I understand.
And in the end ((SPOILERS)) , when Jamie Foxx places the bomb in Butler’s cell and leaves, I felt for Gerard Butler. I did. Again, like Chris Rock said, he was evil, but I understood what got him to that point. And I felt nothing when Jamie Foxx sat with his wife at his daughter’s recital.
This film had Greek Tragedy all over it. It was written and presented that way. If they had marketed it that way, would it have doubled its budget? Probably not. But it could’ve been better received.
Have you seen the film? What did you think? And do you agree with my assessment? Let me know in the comments below!









